Johnny Depp as Puddleglum

[Gwenneth]

My sister and I think Johnny would we awesome as Puddleglum!

I mean, just look at all the roles he's played.
Captain Jack Sparrow.
He can be humourus. And look how much of a pessimist Puddleglum is! He makes me laugh all the time.
And...oh, I've forgotten his name, but that guy in Finding Neverland. He can be serious, too! And Puddleglum definitely shows his serious loyalty at the end of The Silver Chair.

Do you think he'd be good?

[Luthien of Narnia]

I would love to see Johnny in Narnia! I absolutely love him! Yet, I can't picture him as the Puddleglum in my head. Didn't someone involved in the production (Dave Gresham maybe?) suggest that Andrew Adamson be Puddleglum? That I could see happening. But even though Johnny is a versatile actor, he isn't quite right for the feel of the movie. Maybe a Bulgy Bear, lol! Oh, and his name was J.M. Barrie in Finding Neverland.

[.*+Lúth+*.]

I think he would make a great Puddleglum! He just seems to fit the part. He is one of my favorite actors, I think he could pull it off.

[rinielaranel]

eh...I can't see Johnny Depp in Narnia It just doesn't seem to fit for me...

[Gwenneth]

^Aww, really?

I just think he has so much depth.

[Herenya]

*rolls about laughing* that *laughs* is *laughs* so *calms down*

*cracks up again at the thought of Puddleglum fangirls*

Sorry. I'll be sensible now. I think that if Johnny Depp was given the role of Puddleglum, he would do a good job. As you say, he is a versetile actor! However, I'd just never thought of someone like him to play Puddleglum... and I find it hard to imagine him in that role. He doesn't really look like my image of Puddle-glum, and I think he'd do a much better job of a less-depressed character.

Shame he's too old to play Rilian...

[Larael]

Lol I'd love to see Johnny in Narnia, but I don't think he would work as Puddleglum. I think if he played him it would turn out as too much of a laugh seeing as Johnny isn't one to play depressed people. It would be a lot better if he played someonelike Rilian, but alas, he is much too old.

[DLF]

Puddleglum fangirls! *dies* ;D However strange the idea of Johnny Depp as Puddleglum, it'd be worth it just for the amusement quality outside of the movie!
I think he could pull it off well enough, though he'd have to watch the humor.

*has been laughing all this time*